OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
178220763

See my comment on another changeset.
!! don't give generic names. See the warnings about that.
Best regards

178221248

Hello.
See my comment on your mappings.
I adjusted them
Best regards

178235453

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
You managed to map nearly all highways over already mapped highways.
Didn't you zoom in far enough to see all already mapped objects?
Don't give a road a generic name. Just tag it as highway= ....
Best regards

178235453

We welcome you as a new mapper.
Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator to check that the tasks have been mapped in accordance with the quality standards of HOTOSM.
We cannot expect from a new mapper that he/she deliver high-quality mappings from the start, so we offer some guidance.
Please pay attention to the next summarized issues. (see attached document with examples for more info)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Issues found on your mappings
E: Buildings not squared or rounded.
Tagged a wide highwayt (>6 mtr) as a path! This should be mapped as highway=unclassified or residential.
Do no add fancy names to objects. just tag the object.
Empty spots, no shadow are mostly no buildings.
Buildings have in general a rectangular or round form.

Explanation can be found in this document which might be helpful to strengthen your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit

Best regards and keep mapping!
Frans S

178235482

Thank you for mapping. You have correctly identified the location of most objects and mapped.

Reminder: Please be sure to square all rectangular buildings with the Q key
Reviewed by a validator at random or as requested.
FYI. Please view this video about common new mappers mistakes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs5wX592E1o&t=2s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltn1VOiq5_0
In this document, you will find some hints and tricks which might help to expand your mapping skills.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit
Best regards and keep mapping.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/178235482

178235767

Thank you for mapping. You have correctly identified the location of most objects and accurately mapped.

Reminder: Please be sure to square all rectangular buildings with the Q key
Reviewed by a validator at random or as requested.
FYI. Please view this video about common new mappers mistakes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs5wX592E1o&t=2s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltn1VOiq5_0
In this document, you will find some hints and tricks which might help to expand your mapping skills.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit
Best regards and keep mapping.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/178235767

178235707

Thank you for mapping. You have correctly identified the location of most objects and mapped.
A few issues:
Do not include a yard in your mapping.
You mapped over existing mapped buildings. Be sure to zoom in far enough to see all already mapped objects. ( check the bottom line on your editor)

Reminder: Please be sure to square all rectangular buildings with the Q key
Reviewed by a validator at random or as requested.
FYI. Please view this video about common new mappers mistakes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs5wX592E1o&t=2s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltn1VOiq5_0
In this document, you will find some hints and tricks which might help to expand your mapping skills.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit
Best regards and keep mapping.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/178235707

178068184

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Why did you add a layer 1 to a highway.?

way/1473994174/history#map=18/34.122691/66.531932
Don't add these layers unless you are mapping bridges or viaducts.
Best regards

177903685

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Short tracks leading to isolated buildings or company can be tagged as 'service"
Tag highways as 'track'only in cases described in the wiki.
Best regards
Best regards

178193971

Hi. Back again.
Check this wiki please to learn where to use which tag. Important here are
Path, unclassified and tertiary

osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Afghanistan#Values_based_on_economic_and_social_dimension_of_the_road

You see that the tag 'track' is not valid here.
Best regards.

178193971

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Did you read where and how to use the track tag? Here, the traces are so vague and narrow, no traces of traffic by cars.
Retagged to paths.
Best regards

178188247

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
We welcome you as a new mapper.
You did not join the easiest project.
The tracks you located are no roads but rivers/streams.
When you take a close look you will see no traces of traffic but traces of (intermitted) waterways.
I corrected them.
Best regards

177598454

Hello. Thanks for mapping. Well mapped.
About tagging buildings.
Default buildings ought to be tagged as building=yes because we cannot see what the purpose is of a building. We leave that to local mappers.
Please do not cluster buildings eithter.

178175035

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Accurately mapped. However, a few buildings were not squared.
Don't you use the Building Tool plugin?
Then any building you map is rectangular by default (or round).

176629018

Hi I see that you tagged a building with 2 courtyards incorrect.
the building itself and both courtyards are to be mapped as building=yes.
Then make it a multypolygon.
Best regards

176629018

Hi. During a cleanup I came again across duplicated buildings. task 1556.
Are you zooming in far enough ? otherwise, already mapped buildings don't show up.
See this changeset as well.
Changeset: 176661746
I wil remove the duplicated ones.
Best regards

176818824

Hello. thanks for mapping.
Are you aware that you duplicated 112 buildings in this area ? Mainly task 553 and 1551
I removed the duplicated ones.
Never considered changing to JOSM ?
Given the quantity of mappings you deliver, it might be worth it to change.
best regards

178083546

Thanks for mapping. Accurately mapped.
Just a remark on this mapping
way/1474094177/history#map=19/12.105208/15.122364
You mapped both a building. tree and courtyard as 1 building. Check the Mapbox imagery to see what I mean.
I adjusted it.
Best regards and keep mapping

177252875

Thank you for bringing this issue to my attention.
I consulted the wiki
osm.wiki/Indonesian_Tagging_Guidelines#Roads
.
While validating tasks, I regularly came across highways tagged as living_street.
Considering that a ‘living_street’ is generally (from my Western perspective) a road that is specifically designed for pedestrian traffic and local residents, where cars/motorcycles, etc. are banned as much as possible. So I retagged them to
residential highway when I also took the width of such a road into consideration.
I regularly come across incorrectly tagged roads, which I often change to what I consider to be a better tag.
Think of tracks connecting settlements, residential highways in rural areas, paths wide enough to be an unclassified road, etc.
I also see places where a road has been retagged to ‘living street’, when it is actually a connecting road >2.5 meters or more or runs through rural areas. I usually adjust these.

I have changed most (hundreds) of the taggings I changed to residential highways back to ‘living_street’.
It is impossible to name specific locations, because I have validated almost 1300 tasks. An impossible task.
I hope this has provided you with sufficient information.
Kind regards

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

173911384

Hello. Thanks for mapping on this task.
PLease check this footage how to map high buildings.

https://youtu.be/u31wPYWkm3E?si=lDbvDutpUyZWQXXL

Best regards