OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
103331196

Hello, this changeset has removed the building and height tags from this building. Since this is still a building, these are valid tags. Please do not remove valid tags from existing buildings unless you know they are incorrect. Please be more careful in future edits.

102041512

There are a lot of similar issues these same types of changesets have caused, valid data are being removed... I have been trying to fix those that I can find but there are so many... has someone reached out to the owner/organizer of this group for a long term solution?

102059583

Hello, it looks like this changeset has mistakenly removed a number of nodes from adjacent buildings and now those buildings are no longer appropriately represented here. Please be more careful when editing existing buildings.

102056594

Hello, it looks like this changeset has mistakenly enlarged the building here way/257934709 to overlap the hotel building. Since they are separate buildings the footprint of this building should stay the way it was. Please be more careful when updating building footprints to make sure adjacent buildings are not modified when they havent changed.

103261691

Hello, it looks like this changeset removed the building tag on this building. Since this is still a building, the tag should stay on the feature and is valid. Please be more careful in future edits. I have fixed this case.

102115602

Hello, it looks like this changeset removed both the building and building:level tags on this building. Since this building is still here these are valid tags. Please be more careful when changing tags on buildings. These specific tags should have been left as they were on this building. I have already fixed this case.

102130587

Hello, it looks like this changeset removed the building tag on this building. Since its still a building the building=hotel tag is still valid. I have fixed this case but please be more careful in the future.

102110071

Hello, it looks like this changeset removed the building tag on this building. Please do not remove building tags if its still a building. This is still a building so it should be a valid tag to keep.

102050733

I have gone ahead and fixed this case

102050733

Hello, it looks like your changeset deleted the building here: way/43160497. Please do not delete buildings that still exist. Please be more careful when modifying existing buildings.

102410595

Hello, I think you mistakenly removed the building tag on this building. Please be more careful when changing tags on buildings. I have already gone ahead and fixed this one for you.

102060351

Thanks pabi12 for your response on the changesets. As you suggest, I have DM Eddie Cannon to let him know about these kind of issues and he responded that he will be revising the guidance to help accommodate these kinds of things. In the meantime, there are a lot of fixes that other users now need to make... thanks again for your response.

102060180

Hello, it looks like this changeset has removed valid nodes from the adjacent building here and has created an incorrect building outline for the adjacent building. Please be more careful when editing building footprints as some of your changesets are removing valid nodes on accurate building footprints. These buildings will need to be modified to fix the issue.

102060351

Hello, it looks like this changeset removed nodes from the adjacent buildings here and has led to those adjacent buildings to now have incorrect building footprints - note they look like triangles now with 3 nodes instead of squares with 4 nodes... please be more careful when editing buildings, as it seems you are actually removing correct geometry from nearby structures...

102120057

Hello, this changeset removed the building and height tags from this building here when you merged the hotel node to the polygon. The building and height tags are still valid and should not be removed. Building now needs to be updated to return the proper tags to the structure.

102782906

Hello, a large number of your changesets in this area, including this one, where you are merging nodes to buildings is resulting in duplicate information because you are also not then deleting the node you merged. If using iD you can use the merge function on the node and building and it will automatically remove the node. Unfortunately a large number of your changsets in this areas has done this and updates are needed to fix all of them.

102781249

Hello, please be careful when editing existing buildings. You have dropped the height and building tags for this building in this changeset but these are still valid tags. The building needs to be updated to replace these tags.

102112742

Hello, it looks like you have removed the building tag here for this building, this is still a building and it should be placed back on the polygon.

102784290

Hello, it looks like some of your changesets are removing the building tag from the building polygon. Since this is still a building please make sure to keep the building tag. In addition, it looks like you have moved the building outline so its no longer accurate, please do not modify building footprints that already look to be accurate, this polygon is now badly askew and needs to be fixed. In addition I see that when you are merging hotel nodes with buildings you are leaving the node behind, in iD you can merge them which will remove the node when its placed on the building. All your left over nodes should be removed... unfortunately a high number of your changesets in this area all have these same issues...

103170123

Hello, it looks like this changeset moved this building's footprint over the road and misshaped its actual footprint. It looks like you are digitizing buildings using the building roof as it looks on imagery without offsetting to match the actual footprint as it is on the ground due to parallax. The footprint as it was, was pretty accurate and could have been left as is when you did the update. For future edits like this please be more careful as these changes are breaking building footprints and there are more changesets you have that results in the same issue. I have already fixed this case as best I could.