OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
39678815

Hi,
Please don't change residential roads to service roads. Service roads are usually reserved for roads leading only to a specific building, parking. See highway=service

If you think a road is not residential, because there are no houses, use unclassified instead. That wont break routing at least...
I already reverted to residential.

happy mapping

35820740

Hi Elliott,
I see you found the answer already...
Cheers,
Totor

37701644

Hi drivestation,
great edits!
A little tip:
If you have problems making squares or rectangles following bing, in iD you can select the area and then press S to make them square automatically.
Only for areas that are also square in Bing of course...

Other useful shortcuts:
osm.wiki/ID/Shortcuts

37699859

Hi Drivestation,
Is that preschool part of the electric sub-station ?

37684237

Hi Drivestation,

All is ok here. Just a little comment on.... your comment.
Anybody can read the comments you make on changesets. Don't put too many personal information ^_^

37683813

Hi, have a look here:
osm.wiki/Philippines/Mapping_conventions#Barangay_names

37681142

Building are not mandatory ^_^

37681094

Hi, it is ok now. I just added back the building tag, since it looks like there is a building...

37680728

Yes, this is ok now.
I just improved the shape a little to follow the coastline.

37680813

Hi,
I removed your line, and replaced it with just one point.
PS: I can not know you made a comment for me on your own changeset. Only comments on my comments are sent to my inbox.

37663867

This should probably be :
landuse=industrial

and not
building=industrial
I cant imagine that is one big building

37678188

For the refilling station, you could add:
amenity=drinking_water
bottle=yes
fee=yes

37640201

Great correction in 37678188 !

37678084

Hi,
Why did you name it "close road" ?
If this is a private owned road, you can add the tag access=private
(osm.wiki/Access)
If there are barriers at the entrances, you can add one node/point not far from the intersection with the tag "barrier=gate/wall...".
Check here which type is best:
osm.wiki/Barrier

Cheers,
totor

37640238

Hi,
I saw you put back the road in changeset/37678084. great.

37638762

Hi,
I would use:
amenity=school and no building tag.

37638876

Hi,
The School you added, is not the outline of the building, but the outline of the whole school area.
It is better to use amenity=school and to remove the building=yes tag.
The building tag should only be used on the individual buildings.
Happy Mapping,

Totor

37639532

Need help to put back the buildings ?
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=37639532

37639543

Hi Drivestation,
may I ask why you removed those buildings ?
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=37639543
They seem to exist on Bing.
Please understand that other mappers are not happy if you remove their work.
So always delete things with caution.
If there is a good reason, please add a clear changeset description to explain why you removed things.
If it was an accident, no problem, please let me know if you need help, I can help putting them back...

Cheers,

Totor

37640201

Hi,
Great all the features you are adding!
Just a little note:
building=residential is for residential buildings, not filling stations...
Further on, you used it on a land area. The building tag should be used on individual buildings, not on a land area containing buildings.

I would use a smaller building matching the actual building of the filling station, and use building=yes (could be building=retail), amenity=drinking_water, bottle=yes and fee=yes.

links:
osm.wiki/Map_Features#Building
osm.wiki/Philippines/Mapping_conventions#Shops_and_Stores

Cheers,

Totor

.