The primary roads in the south seem wrong - they are not major highways linking large towns. Could you change them to a more appropriate road classification?

Motorway off-ramps like this need to be tagged with motorway_link

This seems to have added something in the middle of nowhere. Was this intentional>

These trails seem to exist - just because they're in a protected area doesn't mean they aren't mappable

Other people have deleted some of your original problem import, so reverting this isn't a route you want to go. Instead, you should do a new import in compliance with the import guidelines.

Hello,

Imports in OSM need to follow the imprt guidelines at wiki.osm.org/Import/Guidelines, which include discussing the proposed import on talk-ca@ and imports@, which you don't seem to have done here.

There's tags like "elev" and "hnumber" in this upload. Where are they from?

Is way/305503671 water? It looks covered

Hi, could you add a source tag for mapping like this to indicate what sources you used?

In JOSM you do this by filling out the "Specify the data source for the changes" field when uploading

Yes.

The parking isles in the school don't seem to match up with either Bing or the 2009 BC Mosaic. Are they newer?

Hello,

This appears to be an undiscussed import. Imports in OSM need to follow wiki.osm.org/Import/Guidelines, which include consulting with imports@ and the local community. This is because of past experience with imports.

Have you done this? I couldn't find a posting on the imports@ mailing list. If you haven't, you'll need to stop the import until you consult with the community, including imports@.

Paul Norman
For the Data Working Group

Hi,

When you use a comment like "Test" it makes it hard for others to understand what you were doing. For example, I can't figure out what way/376870750 is supposed to be

It looks like this removed information and din't replace it. Should it be undone?

Sorry, I had missed this reply.

Google's terms for their public services prevent you from using them to build your own map. For example, you can only geocode with them if you're going to be displaying the result on a Google map.

It doesn't look like this import was properly proposed, so should probably be reverted.

There's some odd gas stations in this, like way/61247009

Is this the actual signed name of the trail, or a description of it? In OSM we use the name tag only for names

You've tagged a house as Jackson's House. Is this an actual name of the house, or were you just indicating that someone named Jackson lives there?

Hi,

In OpenStreetMap we don't record private information like this that others won't be able to verify. There are tools like http://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/ which allow you to overlay points on top of OpenStreetMap, if that's what you want to do.