שלום נחל יתלה,

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM!

בבקשה אל תוסיף למפה הפומבית נקודות אישיות או הנחיות לטיולים אישיים.
לשם כך, תוכל ליצור מסלולים, לשמור אותם בענן ולשתף עם מי שתרצה.

תודה!

way/1299455967
has no traces on the ground:
osm.wiki/Good_practice#Map_what's_on_the_ground

Please avoid mapping of historic places:
osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_historic_events_and_historic_features

By now, two other historic places have been deleted.

Hi,
Should
node/11642438105
also have "foot=yes"?

הנקודה לא מוגדרת כחניון יום אלא כ
amenity=parking
name=חניון יום קניון שחורת

אני מבין שאתה מסכים עם השינוי שאני עשיתי ל-
amenity=parking

אני מסכים שאפשר למחוק את השם. זו בסה"כ חניה, לא חניון יום ולא חניון לילה. השם נשאר, כנראה, מרוב הגלגולים שהנקודה הזו עברה.

Neither do I. It was mapped 3 years ago on a visit.
I can only guess that all the numbers there are for the חוד עקב street, but your guess is as good as mine

Hi, Please feel free to do that

Fixed in changeset/175417196

Apparently, also a surprise for me, there is no such implication....

Hello Yitzchak,

Thank you for your contributions to OSM!

In this edit, you have added this debris barrier
node/11980696745

Please note that by default of the Graphhopper router, and potentially other OSM-based routing engins, such a barrier does not preclude pansage by foot, bike, or car. For example:
https://graphhopper.com/maps/?point=31.817319%2C34.98171&point=31.816704%2C34.981723&profile=car&layer=OpenStreetMap

Please add "access", "bicycle", and/or "motor_vehicle" tags if applicable.

See changeset/172060156#c1515009

See changeset/172060156#c1515009

Hi Popolon,

Thank you for your many contributions to OSM!

In this edit you have added an "illegal settlement" value to the place tag of way/742606938.

In the description of changeset/172060038 you wrote: "add some buildings orchards and greenhouse to keep a trace if even israel terrorist and geneocidary state destroy them"

Please avoid using OSM as a platform for expressing political views.

Best regards,
zstadler

IMO, there was no need to revert that edit. Everything but the "name" tag seems fine.

For the first or second edit of a new user, this seems like a reasonable error that has a harsh response from the community.
A more welcoming response could have been chosen

Hello Tabib1243,

Thank you for your contributions to OSM.

Please avoid deleting on-the-ground elements, such as this cistern.

You are more than welcome to improve the map with additional names.

This deletion was reverted in changeset/174615355

Hello Jules,

Thank you for responding. I also appreciate that you see the issue with respect to changing name tags in relation/1703814 and the fact that you kept the "disputed=yes" tag on both.

As far as I'm aware, there is no "State of Palestine" with on-the-ground country institutions beyond the powers given to the Palestinian Authority, as part of the Oslo Accords.

On the technical side, this edit created an inconsistency between the relation name tags and the name tags on its label member.

I agree with the DWG position on making name changes in areas under conflict. Let's hope that the Palestinian and the Israeli people will reach a peaceful agreement for a conflict that is already more than a century old.

Hello Jules,

I understand you wanted to make a political statement about the Palestinian issue.

The truth on the ground is that there is no state named "Palestine".

On the ground, the governance of the Palestinian Territories is according to the Oslo Accords, where the Palestinian Authority and Israel have split responsibilities in the West Bank.

Please refrain from using OSM for making political statements.

עכשיו שני יחסים שנקראים "מסע מים אל ים":

1. קטע מערבי, שעודכן בעריכה הזו,
relation/15993350
מחוף הים ועד דרך העפר בכניסה לנחל כזיב, שמוגדר כמסלול מקומי network=lwn

2. קטע מזרחי, מדרך העפר ועד הכנרת
relation/2860967
שמוגדר כמסלול אזורי network=rwn

אולי כדאי לאחד אותם ליחס אחד?

In changeset/173701141 I have removed way/691031950 as an inner member of way/966155213 and kept it only as an outer member.

Hello Flayer,

In this changeset you have modified
relation/9602782 - a landuse=forest multipolygon

The outer member of the polygon - way/966155213 was deleted, and now way/691031950 is both an outer member and an inner member.

Can you please fix it?

Thanks!

Yes. I think we're good!