Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 176732794 | Please don't accuse "vandalistic" when this is a suspected act. Don't change `old_name=` to `name=` without discussion. |
|
| 176775325 | Please upload your edits in the same area together. Don't update 1 object per changeset. changeset/176728421 |
|
| 176776123 | @kingkingHK No, it's another attribute. `opening_hours=` is not fully standard for `access=` and `highway=` open=* |
|
| 176660813 | 2. You confused 397 ("Prison") and 399 ("Correctional Institution")
|
|
| 176660813 | Please don't remove `amenity=` + `name=` |
|
| 176661084 | Please don't remove, or delete other `building=` |
|
| 176728421 | Please upload your edits in the same area together. Don't update 1 object per changeset. |
|
| 176700024 | 1. Please don't remove other names. All are valid.
|
|
| 175434034 | 3. No, it can contradict the Categories rule, even for what's in fact 3 corridors with 2 east-west. You should not use `route=` simply for this. It's not a transport planning policy tool. It's for reflecting a signposted, official, or numbered one. |
|
| 175434034 | 1.1. No, the ground truth principle can't be disproved. As I said, the standard and expectation for `route=` is higher. Even if you want to argue it's commonly used by people, it's unable to be distinguished whether it's proper, or a descriptor as a category.
|
|
| 175434034 | 1. This is not my "personal preference". I'm explaining to you on the `route=` , not other `highway=` roads. Wuhu St Underpass is used on traffic notices, and Schedule of Routes, to refer to the road. "Footbridge System" is a specific set of interconnected footbridges, but is at least not a `route=` , and not rigorously a `network=` either.
|
|
| 175434034 | 1. This is a `route=` , which has higher expectations and standards
|
|
| 176537259 | That's Nominatim's fault. It overwrites the `admin_level=` with the `label` `place=` `address_rank:` counterintuitively. Has already been worked around with `admin_centre` yesterday. Need to wait for it to update or something. |
|
| 176416923 | This section is embanked, not bridged continuously. You can see the joint easily on the span across Lin Cheung Rd on the east. |
|
| 176216186 | 2. The street naming isn't very useful, and it's quite unique to HK. `street:name=` should be enough for gazetted street, and `=motorway_link` can be named by interchanges. |
|
| 176216186 | This should not be followed, as it's inconsistent. Eg Rt 3 ends on an Exit in WHC. It may be taken to mean the km measuring only. |
|
| 175434034 | 1. If there's not a signposted or official extent, it should not be added
|
|
| 176206974 | The slip roads are made `=motorway` for the existing status (cf TMCLK, TKOLTT) |
|
| 176183288 | Please don't delete `area:highway=` |
|
| 176182825 | 1. Please discuss this first before changing all of them. They are 25kV_ac KCR sizes, built as mainline national rail, and functions as suburban trains. The existing compromise is to use `route=subway` on the `railway=rail`
|