OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
179643621

Please don't delete valid data. This is the common form of architecture in HK.

179639745

+ `location=underground`

179639745

Please use `building=` , not `landuse=`

179592074

Please don't combine names in `name=` , which are for proper names only. Shared campuses should be `landuse=education` , and can have no `name=` fine. They should be 2 `=school` points inside.

179497024

You can compare eg `maxspeed:type=` still adding `maxspeed=`

179566374

It's the `sidewalk=no` , and needs to be distinguished from `foot=no` , but should add `foot:signed=none`

179497024

Why are you delete them???

179369541

`=house` is a single home. Multiple homes should be `=terrace`

179368028

1. When the estate is simply number on street, it should be `noname=yes` , as there's no difference with the addressing. Only styled ones eg `=328 Clear Water Bay` should be accepted.
2. Blocks in estate use `addr:street` + `addr:housenumber=` + `addr:unit=`

179293455

HK BBQ should be eg `=picnic_site` + ` bbq=yes` + `fee=yes` ( `amenity=bbq` has been defined for individual grills) , surely not `=restaurant`

179251791

1. If they are same factory, a `landuse=industrial` + `=works` polygon should be drawn around them, not duplicated as 2 `=works`
2. If it's small scale only, it should use `craft=` , not `=works`

179256033

Sewage pumping stations should use `=pumping_station` , not `=wastewater_plant`

179251994

What is Pik Uk Garden? If it's an estate, it should be `landuse=residential` , not `=hamlet`

179235318

Please don't add such `name=` , which is for proper names only. `temporary=yes` should be used.

179184501

First of all, you can't claim it's a typo. As you have cited it, it must be assumed to be used. This defense won't work regardless of whether it's somehow an honest mistake.
Here, you deleted rectangular shapes, and redrew them as non-rectangular. That's already wrong.
Therefore you have caused no net benefit there. You should have only added `addr:*=` to the existing `building=` , not all these changes. You simply raise more suspicion by redrawing them.

179167947

Please use `*:yue-Latn=` for romanization without commonly recognized and used status, not `*:en=`

179196155

Please don't undisussed bulk change from `old_name=` to other `*name=` , and accuse others of vandalisms. You are only accusing yourself together. Use OpenHistoricalMap.

179196073

There's no `=peak` if it has become flattened with the surroundings entirely. Only `place=locality` , and it should be on OpenHistoricalMap instead.

179199146

Did you check whether others have politely commented on you already? You will see how well your report do for yourself.

179197177

changeset/179199146 Please read your own changesets if you know how to comment changeset/179184501