OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
177934866

No, I believe you should discuss any mass re-tagging. `{{PossibleSynonym}}` has not been used on wiki yet either.
Yes, I have documented it myself osm.wiki/Proposal:Crosswalk_clean-up#Crosswalk_as_lines
Another use for this is allowing regex or prefix search of `footway=crossing*` for all crosswalk parts. `=traffic_island` would need an union, and excluding non-crosswalk traffic island walkways.

177934866

It would at least need to be distinguished by `traffic_island=` `=crossing` vs `=platform`

177934866

Where has this been discussed? I don't favor `=traffic_island` as it may be used for the `=footway` connecting to transit platforms.

177963900

First of all, `building=terrace` must be wrong. It's used on the entire row, not individual houses, which is `=house` + `house=terraced`
Regardless, these debates really shows `=house` + `house=` being superior. Leaves arguing the attribute, instead of feature.

177963900

What does that mean?

161456988

It's `disused=yes` vs `abandoned:highway=` not `highway=` + `abandoned=yes`

177817504

Please don't delete, but change enclosed `building=` to `building:part=`

177832329

Please don't merge `building=` area with site grounds area. They are different

177747731

0. Please use meaningful upload comments
1. Please don't upload personal test data or similar

177745428

This should be `description=`

177745428

`name=` is for proper names, not descriptive titles. These `name=` should be official as in survey sheets.

177719323

You missed the point. The difference is whether they are physical structures, or functional activities. Unused roads, buildings, towers, etc still exist. Unused services, no longer.

177675215

`destination:ref=` is when the road only goes to that route. This is `destination:ref:to=`

177697839

1. Please don't remove Chinese from `name=` , which should be bilingual
2. If it has offices etc other uses, it should be `=commercial` or `=industrial` , not `=service`
3. `website=` is the page specific to the facility. Please use eg `operator:website=`

177719323

`disused=yes` is not Troll on `highway=`

177647860

Please use `change=no`

177649672

Please don't draw a pair of lines when there's no raised separation. Use `share_taxi:backward=no`

177444748

https://www.mtr.com.hk/en/corporate/tenders/TUE_C12003.html ?

177444748

https://mtrtungchunglineextension.hk/tung-chung-east/ ?

177519080

1. Government or official documents often capitalize a term to distinguish it. That doesn't necessarily mean it's a proper noun. You can also find many "former".
2. I said `old_name=` , not `name=`